Show Filters

78 Results

Price Range

  • Min Price
  • Max Price

Year Range

  • Min Year
  • Max Year

Category

  • Football
  • Baseball
  • Basketball
  • Hockey
  • Soccer
  • College Sports
  • Golf
  • UFC
  • Boxing
  • Formula1
  • NASCAR
  • WWE
  • Veefriends
  • Pokemon
  • Marvel
  • One Piece
  • Disney
  • Star Wars
  • Entertainment
  • Kids Club
  • Bo Battle Arena
  • TCG
  • Tennis
  • Magic the Gathering
  • Other

Players

  • Matthew Schaefer

Team

Card Type

  • Graded
  • Raw
  • Sealed Wax

Listing Type

  • Buy Now
  • Cash Offers
  • Trade
  • Auction
  • Taking offers (no list price)

Seller Status

  • Verified
  • Unverified

Grading

  • 10
  • 9.5
  • 9
  • 8.5
  • 8
  • 7.5
  • 7
  • 6.5
  • 6
  • 5.5
  • 5
  • 4.5
  • 4
  • 3.5
  • 3
  • 2.5
  • 2
  • 1.5
  • 1
  • Authentic

Professional Grader

  • PSA
  • SGC
  • BGS
  • CSG
  • CGC
  • BCCG
  • BVG
  • HGA
  • KSA
  • TAG
  • GMA
  • MNT
  • Rare Edition
  • BAS
  • FCG
  • ISA
  • GSG
  • PGS
  • TCG
  • Arena Club
  • GAI
  • AGS
  • GAS
  • C3
  • TGA
  • degree
  • ECC
  • Other

Attribute

  • Rookie
  • Serial Numbered
  • Autograph
  • Patch
  • Memorabila
  • Short Print
  • Refractor
  • Insert
  • Parallel
  • 1/1
  • Set
  • Case Hits
  • Vintage
  • Foil
  • Lot
  • Jersey Numbered

Seller Location

  • US
  • Canada

Seller Currency

  • USD
  • CAD

Exclude My Cards

  • Exclude My Cards

Listings from Users I Follow

  • Listings from Users I Follow

Best Price Badge

  • Best Price Badge

Video added

  • Video added
2025-26 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer SGC 10
$90.00
SuperiorSportsCards
26-27 UD series one fan faves 6 card lot
$10.00
Collectingwithrand
2025-26 Upper Deck Allure Matthew Schaefer SGC 10
$100.00
SuperiorSportsCards
Matthew Schaefer 2025-26 NHL Star Rookies #5
$10.00
Verification Badge
Mo.cards
Matthew Schaefer 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 #451 PSA 9
$220.00
Verification Badge
Mo.cards
Matthew Schaefer Orange Slice Rookie
$25.00
Verification Badge
Kingscollectibles
2024 Team Canada Juniors Matthew Schaefer Auto
$200.00
Verification Badge
BraydenSegat
2026 Spx Matthew Schaefer Blue Rookies Auto /99
$450.00
Verification Badge
UncleBuc Collectibles
Matthew Schaefer Rookie Credentials Sensational Youth /99
$75.00
Jdunn622
2025-26 Skybox Metal Universe Matthew Schaefer Fresh Foundation PSA 9
$46.35
Impact-sportscards
Matthew Schaefer Debut Ticket Access Auto /99
$700.00
Kmars16
2025-26 Ice - Matthew Schaefer - Premieres Rookie Jersey patch - #IPJ-MS
$100.00
puckme35
2025-26 Ice - Matthew Schaefer - Breaking the Ice -
$50.00
puckme35
2025-26 Ice - Matthew Schaefer - Premieres Rookie auto /199 - #IPA-MS
$700.00
puckme35
2025-26 Upper Deck S2 Matthew Schaefer Young Guns 451 BGS 9.5 Gem Mint W/10
$475.00
Verification Badge
BraydenSegat
Upper Deck Clear Cut UD Canvas Rookie Debut Matthew Schaefer Islanders CD-MS
$112.45
RicoCardz
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Premier Matthew Schaefer RC #P-92 OPC Rookie Islanders
$25.00
pincman_cards
25/26 UD CLEAR CUT ROOKIE AUTOGRAPH #CC-MS MATTHEW SCHAEFER RC (150/199)
$597.37
Maximum Cards & Collectibles
2025 Upper Deck Ud Canvas Matthew Schaefer
$386.54
RicoCardz
2026-27 Artifacts #134 Matthew Schaefer Stars /699
$6.99
Verification Badge
BearRidge
2025-26 UD OPC Platinum Matthew Schaefer Marquee Rookie Rainbow #268
$42.16
Maximum Cards & Collectibles
2026-27 Artifacts #134 Matthew Schaefer Stars Ruby /499
$9.99
Verification Badge
BearRidge
2025-26 Clear Cut UD Canvas Rookie Debuts #CD-MS Matthew Schaefer
$115.00
lithiumturtle
Matthew Schaefer Pond Hockey Platinum 2025-26
$395.00
Verification Badge
Irvgoat
O-Pee-Chee 2025-26 Marquee Rookie Red Matthew Schaefer #592 PSA 10 - POP 1
$948.78
Verification Badge
Stells20
Matthew Schaefer 2025 DC Fanimation Crossover Superman SSP Auto
$9,048.00
WeWantTheCup
2025-26 Clear Cut - Matthew Schaefer - Blue Dazzler auto
$800.00
puckme35
2025-26 O-Pee-Chee Marquee Rookie Yellow SP Matthew Schaefer PSA 10
$759.02
Verification Badge
Stells20
Matthew Schaefer Rookie Holograms
$60.00
ThornedBear
2025-26 Upper Deck Premier Matthew Schaefer
$40.00
Verification Badge
NYIslandersFan
2025-26 Upper Deck Premier Matthew Schaefer Rookie Jersey
$65.00
RATHBUNT
Matthew Schaefer 2025-26 SPx SuperScripts Rookie Auto PSA 10
$1,750.00
Castaway Collectibles
Matthew Schaefer 746 First 1st Round Draft 2025-26 Upper Deck Extended RC
$10.54
Verification Badge
BLNCards
2025-26 SP Authentic Matthew Schaefer Future Watch Spectrum FX Level 3
$65.00
Verification Badge
ryzerman77
2025 Upper Deck Ud Canvas Matthew Schaefer Ud Canvas-Black & White PSA 10
$2,000.00
Verification Badge
NYIslandersFan
2025 Upper Deck Sp Game Used Inked Rookie Sweaters Matthew Schaefer Inked Rookie Sweaters-Patch PSA 7
$800.00
Verification Badge
NYIslandersFan
2025 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer PSA 10
$1,000.00
Verification Badge
NYIslandersFan
2025 Spx Autographs Matthew Schaefer Autograph-Blue PSA 9
$750.00
Verification Badge
NYIslandersFan
2025 Upper Deck Canvas Matthew Schaefer RC PSA 10
$275.00
OILERFAN99
2025-26 O Pee Chee Platinum Neon Yellow Surge Matthew Schaefer Rookie #268
$100.00
Obeedoh’s Cards
MATTHEW SCHAEFER 2025 UD ALLURE COLOR FLOW RC RED/ORANGE SP #CF-MS PSA 10 GEM MT
$200.00
Verification Badge
Johnny I Hockey Cards
Matthew Schaefer 2025-26 Series 2 Young Guns
$200.00
Verification Badge
jc_filthycards
2025-26 Skybox Metal Universe Fresh Foundation Matthew Schaefer
$100.00
Creaturesrock
2025 Upper Deck Nhl New Arrivals Matthew Schaefer Blue
$100.00
Creaturesrock
2025-26 Future Watch Spectrum FX Level 3 Matthew Schaefer Rookie RC Unscratched
$65.00
Panarinoid Android
2025-26 Upper Deck O-Pee-Chee Gold Glossy RC Matthew Schaefer
$9.14
Sitka
Matthew Schaefer Young Guns Jumbo
$25.00
Verification Badge
Pig’s Eye Cards
Matthew Schaefer Power Play Rookies /199
$50.00
Jdunn622
2025 Upper Deck Allure Extended Rookies Matthew Schaefer PSA 10
$125.00
Verification Badge
UncleBuc Collectibles
Matthew Schaefer Metal Purple Spectrum FX /199
$150.00
DZ_Hockey