Marketplace Safety Guide

Home      Marketplace Safety

My Card Post is built on trust between collectors. Most members are honest, but a little homework goes a long way, especially on high-value deals or deals with new members.

Before you deal with a new member, check

  1. Their deal history. Completed trades and sales on My Card Post, and their feedback from other members.
  2. Verification. Members with a verified badge have confirmed their identity.
  3. Their profile. A profile photo, linked social accounts (Instagram, Facebook, X), and linked marketplace profiles like eBay with real feedback.
  4. Their listings. Clear, well-lit photos of the actual card, not stock images.
  5. Graded cards. Look up the cert number on the grader's site (PSA, SGC, CGC, TAG) and make sure it matches the card in the photos.

Payments and shipping

  • Always pay with PayPal Goods & Services on platform. Never pay via Friends & Family, Zelle, Venmo, or Cash App outside of My Card Post.
  • If someone asks you to pay another way, that's a red flag. Report it.
  • Ship within 48 hours and add tracking to the deal.
  • In trades, both sides ship at the same time. Don't hold your cards while waiting to see if the other side ships.

Red flags

  • Asking you to pay or move the deal outside My Card Post
  • Pushing you to rush, or offering a deal that seems too good to be true
  • Refusing to share tracking, or new photos of the card

Start small. With a new member, do a smaller deal first and build from there.

Something feel off? Use the report button on the deal or message, or email support@mycardpost.com. I review every report personally.