1958 Topps - Sport Magazine '58 All Star Selection Mickey Mantle HOF #487 PSA 4+

$349.00 (USD)
+ US $5.17 shipping (US)
1d ago
  ( )
  deals
PayPal Paid through PayPal Goods & Services. Eligible purchases covered by PayPal Purchase Protection.
Sold comps for this card
Tap a grade to see its sales
$322.25Last sale · Nov 9, 2026
$323.9190-day average (14 sales)
12-month price history
$250 $300 $349
11/11 1/23 3/24 6/21 8/29 11/9
Recent sales
$322.25 Nov 9, 2026 eBay · Auction
$323.96 Nov 8, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$375.00 Nov 1, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$350.00 Oct 29, 2026 eBay · BIN
$305.00 Oct 29, 2026 eBay · Auction
$400.00 Oct 27, 2026 · outside typical range Fanatics · BIN
$319.99 Oct 27, 2026 eBay · BIN
$305.00 Oct 26, 2026 eBay · Auction
$352.00 Oct 23, 2026 eBay · Auction
$290.00 Oct 22, 2026 eBay · BIN
$321.51 Oct 22, 2026 eBay · Auction
$325.00 Oct 22, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$305.00 Oct 21, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$325.00 Oct 21, 2026 eBay · BIN
$315.00 Oct 20, 2026 eBay · Auction
Matched on: Mickey Mantle 1958 Topps All Star Baseball (cert-verified) · Wrong card?
Average of 14 sales since Oct 20, 2026. Recent player performance can move prices faster than sales data reports it. Comp data powered by Card Hedge. Market reference data from recent public sales, not an appraisal.
Population report
3,166
PSA 4 Pop
8,138
Pop Higher
17,024
Total PSA
By Grading Company Graded · Gem rate
PSA PSA 17,024 · 0.0%
SGC SGC 7,356 · 0.0%
Beckett Beckett 2,332 · 0.0%
CGC CGC 368 · 0.0%
Total 27,080 · 0.0%
Full grade table
Grade PSAPSA SGCSGC BeckettBeckett CGCCGC
9 51 2 – –
8.5 17 8 10 –
8 701 51 57 1
7.5 45 69 71 6
7 1,443 227 138 13
6.5 82 119 153 21
6 2,343 482 233 33
5.5 135 347 263 27
5 2,547 1,023 285 44
4.5 179 591 262 30
4 3,166 1,072 227 31
3.5 227 367 184 23
Total 17,024 7,356 2,332 368
Pop data powered by GemRate, updated Nov 9, 2026. Counts change as new cards are graded.
Card details

You are purchasing a 1958 Topps Mickey Mantle #487 [Base] Base Set PSA 4. You will receive the exact item in the photographs. Thank you for looking.


Listed With Mascot.

Listed1 day ago
Card TypeGraded
GraderPSA
Grade4
CategoryBaseball
Additional Cards RateUS $0.69 (US) each
More from Premier Card Collectors