1996 Score Derek Jeter Rookie #240 CGC 9.5 New York Yankees

$44.03 (USD)
+ US $5.80 shipping (US)
1h ago
NE, United States
  ( )
  deals
Paid member
PayPal Paid through PayPal Goods & Services. Eligible purchases covered by PayPal Purchase Protection.
Sold comps for this card
$16.59Last sale · Oct 8, 2024
5Sales on record
Recent sales
$10 $20 $30 $44
2/26 6/3 2/27 3/13 10/8
Recent sales
$16.59 Oct 8, 2024 eBay · Auction
$9.60 Mar 13, 2023 Fanatics · Auction
$9.60 Feb 27, 2023 Fanatics · Auction
$26.00 Jun 3, 2022 eBay · Auction
$39.99 Feb 26, 2022 eBay · Auction
Matched on: Derek Jeter 1996 Score Baseball (cert-verified) · Wrong card?
Based on 5 sales on record, the latest on Oct 8, 2024. Recent player performance can move prices faster than sales data reports it. Comp data powered by Card Hedge. Market reference data from recent public sales, not an appraisal.
Population report
16
CGC 9.5 Pop
10
Pop Higher
112
Total CGC
8.9%
Gem Rate
By Grading Company Graded · Gem rate
PSA PSA 1,555 · 28.0%
SGC SGC 216 · 9.3%
Beckett Beckett 188 · 36.2%
CGC CGC 112 · 8.9%
Total 2,071 · 25.7%
Full grade table
Grade PSAPSA SGCSGC BeckettBeckett CGCCGC
Pristine 10 – – 2 –
10 435 20 – 10
9.5 • – 32 66 16
9 604 86 53 45
8.5 6 35 37 14
8 254 23 10 13
7.5 1 2 13 4
7 117 6 1 2
6.5 1 – 2 3
6 74 4 2 –
5.5 – 1 – –
5 30 5 1 1
Total 1,555 216 188 112
Pop data powered by GemRate, updated Nov 10, 2026. Counts change as new cards are graded.
Card details

1996 Score #240 Derek Jeter rookie card from the New York Yankees, graded CGC 9.5. This Score issue is one of the key early cards for Jeter and comes from his 1996 baseball season, when he was establishing himself with the Yankees. The card is slabbed for protection and identification, making it a solid graded example for collectors building around Jeter, the Yankees, or 1990s baseball sets.

Listed1 hour ago
Card TypeGraded
GraderCGC
Grade9.5
CategoryBaseball
More from Mascot