1960 Baseball Carl Mathias #139 Rookie

$4.65 (USD)
+ US $5.80 shipping (US)
1h ago
NE, United States
  ( )
  deals
Paid member
PayPal Paid through PayPal Goods & Services. Eligible purchases covered by PayPal Purchase Protection.
Sold comps for this card
$2.75Last sale · Oct 18, 2026
15Sales on record
Recent sales
$2 $3 $5
3/24 4/26 5/25 6/27 9/29 10/18
Recent sales
$2.75 Oct 18, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$1.19 Oct 17, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$1.97 Oct 14, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$1.50 Sep 29, 2026 eBay · BIN
$2.89 Aug 7, 2026 eBay · BIN
$1.29 Jul 11, 2026 eBay · BIN
$2.70 Jun 27, 2026 eBay · BIN
$1.23 Jun 8, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$2.99 May 25, 2026 eBay · Auction
$1.89 May 16, 2026 eBay · Auction
$1.47 May 10, 2026 eBay · BIN
$1.25 Apr 26, 2026 eBay · Auction
$4.00 Apr 15, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$2.15 Apr 14, 2026 eBay · Auction
$1.49 Mar 24, 2026 eBay · Auction
Matched on: Carl Mathias 1960 Topps Baseball Rookie Star (title match) · Wrong card?
Based on 15 sales on record, the latest on Oct 18, 2026. Recent player performance can move prices faster than sales data reports it. Comp data powered by Card Hedge. Market reference data from recent public sales, not an appraisal.
Card details

1960 Baseball card #139 features Carl Mathias of the Cleveland Indians and is presented here in Excellent condition. This rookie card comes from the 1960 baseball set and is a solid addition for collectors building around the Indians, rookie issues, or mid-century baseball cards.

Listed1 hour ago
Card TypeRaw
CategoryBaseball
More from Mascot