1959 Topps Willie Mays PSA 4.5

$299.99 (USD)
+ US $7.00 shipping (US)
7 views 3 watching 22d ago
Tennessee, United States
  ( )
  deals
Paid member
PayPal Paid through PayPal Goods & Services. Eligible purchases covered by PayPal Purchase Protection.
Sold comps for this card
$300.00Last sale · Oct 31, 2026
15Sales on record
12-month price history
$200 $250 $300
3/19 4/11 6/29 8/23 9/15 10/31
Recent sales
$300.00 Oct 31, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$291.51 Sep 15, 2026 eBay · Auction
$325.00 Aug 23, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$274.99 Jun 28, 2026 eBay · Auction
$189.99 Apr 10, 2026 eBay · Auction
$249.99 Mar 19, 2026 eBay · Auction
$255.00 Oct 25, 2025 eBay · Auction
$224.50 Aug 24, 2025 eBay · Auction
$225.00 Jul 7, 2025 eBay · Best Offer
$299.99 Sep 12, 2024 eBay · Auction
$172.50 Jul 26, 2024 eBay · Auction
$270.00 Apr 28, 2024 eBay · Auction
$260.00 Feb 23, 2024 eBay · Auction
$227.51 Jan 28, 2024 eBay · Auction
$210.01 Sep 3, 2023 eBay · Auction
Matched on: Willie Mays 1959 Topps Baseball (cert-verified) · Wrong card?
Based on 15 sales on record, the latest on Oct 31, 2026. Recent player performance can move prices faster than sales data reports it. Comp data powered by Card Hedge. Market reference data from recent public sales, not an appraisal.
Population report
117
PSA 4.5 Pop
4,008
Pop Higher
7,921
Total PSA
0.1%
Gem Rate
By Grading Company Graded · Gem rate
PSA PSA 7,921 · 0.1%
SGC SGC 3,272 · 0.0%
Beckett Beckett 869 · 0.0%
CGC CGC 148 · 0.0%
Total 12,210 · 0.0%
Full grade table
Grade PSAPSA SGCSGC BeckettBeckett CGCCGC
10 5 – – –
9 47 3 2 –
8.5 32 15 5 –
8 401 33 20 5
7.5 27 44 37 2
7 822 126 49 3
6.5 62 64 69 8
6 1,165 226 73 12
5.5 87 177 110 11
5 1,155 470 92 17
4.5 • 117 266 88 18
4 1,451 486 87 12
Total 7,921 3,272 869 148
Pop data powered by GemRate, updated Nov 22, 2026. Counts change as new cards are graded.
Card details
Listed3 weeks ago
AttributesVintage
Card TypeGraded
GraderPSA
Grade4.5
CategoryBaseball
Year1959
Additional Cards RateUS $0.50 (US) each
More from Crosscards