1958 Topps M. Mantle H. Aaron #418 W. S. Batting Foes PSA 4

$533.92 (USD)
+ US $5.54 shipping (US)
1h ago
NE, United States
  ( )
  deals
Paid member
PayPal Paid through PayPal Goods & Services. Eligible purchases covered by PayPal Purchase Protection.
Sold comps for this card
Tap a grade to see its sales
$336.00Last sale · Jan 12, 2026
15Sales on record
Recent sales
$250 $300 $534
1/28 3/24 7/24 9/3 5/2 1/12
Recent sales
$336.00 Jan 12, 2026 Fanatics · Auction
$247.50 Jul 13, 2024 eBay · Auction
$276.55 May 6, 2024 eBay · Auction
$256.00 May 2, 2024 eBay · Auction
$325.00 Apr 18, 2024 eBay · Auction
$220.00 Mar 8, 2024 eBay · Auction
$270.00 Sep 3, 2023 eBay · Auction
$341.00 Aug 24, 2023 eBay · Auction
$324.00 Jul 24, 2023 Fanatics · Auction
$250.00 Apr 30, 2023 eBay · Auction
$301.77 Apr 21, 2023 eBay · Auction
$260.00 Mar 24, 2023 eBay · Auction
$289.95 Feb 24, 2023 eBay · Auction
$299.99 Feb 18, 2023 eBay · Auction
$325.00 Jan 28, 2023 eBay · Auction
Matched on: Mickey Mantle 1958 Topps World Series Batting Baseball (cert-verified) · Wrong card?
Based on 15 sales on record, the latest on Jan 12, 2026. Recent player performance can move prices faster than sales data reports it. Comp data powered by Card Hedge. Market reference data from recent public sales, not an appraisal.
Population report
1,622
PSA 4 Pop
3,351
Pop Higher
7,984
Total PSA
By Grading Company Graded · Gem rate
PSA PSA 7,984 · 0.0%
Beckett Beckett 974 · 0.0%
CGC CGC 147 · 0.7%
SGC SGC 15 · 0.0%
Total 9,120 · 0.0%
Full grade table
Grade PSAPSA BeckettBeckett CGCCGC SGCSGC
10 – – 1 –
9.5 – – 1 –
9 15 – – –
8.5 – 3 – –
8 163 8 1 –
7.5 11 16 – 2
7 489 38 2 –
6.5 13 36 6 –
6 1,118 69 4 4
5.5 41 111 12 3
5 1,212 108 15 2
4.5 48 109 10 –
Total 7,984 974 147 15
Pop data powered by GemRate, updated Nov 7, 2026. Counts change as new cards are graded.
Card details

1958 Topps #418 W. S. Batting Foes featuring M. Mantle and H. Aaron, graded PSA 4. This Topps issue from the 1958 baseball set pairs two of the era’s most recognized hitters on the same card, making it a key name combination for collectors of postwar baseball. The card is part of the W. S. Batting Foes subset and reflects the design and player pairing format used in the 1958 Topps release.

Listed1 hour ago
Card TypeGraded
GraderPSA
Grade4
CategoryBaseball
More from Mascot