1957 Topps Ted Williams #1 PSA 5

$539.31 (USD)
+ US $5.38 shipping (US)
1d ago
NE, United States
  ( )
  deals
Paid member
PayPal Paid through PayPal Goods & Services. Eligible purchases covered by PayPal Purchase Protection.
Sold comps for this card
$675.00Last sale · Oct 10, 2026
$479.7090-day average (10 sales)
12-month price history
$400 $800 $1,000 $539
11/3 2/2 4/7 5/25 8/24 10/10
Recent sales
$675.00 Oct 10, 2026 · outside typical range eBay · BIN
$504.00 Oct 4, 2026 Fanatics · Auction
$500.00 Sep 28, 2026 Fanatics · BIN
$521.00 Sep 22, 2026 eBay · Auction
$462.00 Sep 18, 2026 Alt · Auction
$475.00 Sep 7, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$520.00 Aug 25, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$449.00 Aug 24, 2026 eBay · BIN
$450.00 Aug 21, 2026 eBay · BIN
$413.00 Aug 4, 2026 eBay · Auction
$503.00 Jul 24, 2026 eBay · Auction
$450.00 Jul 7, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$454.99 Jul 6, 2026 eBay · Auction
$385.00 May 31, 2026 eBay · Best Offer
$326.00 May 31, 2026 · outside typical range eBay · Auction
Matched on: Ted Williams 1957 Topps Baseball (cert-verified) · Wrong card?
Average of 10 sales since Jul 24, 2026. Recent player performance can move prices faster than sales data reports it. Comp data powered by Card Hedge. Market reference data from recent public sales, not an appraisal.
Population report
1,099
PSA 5 Pop
1,920
Pop Higher
7,271
Total PSA
0.0%
Gem Rate
By Grading Company Graded · Gem rate
PSA PSA 7,271 · 0.0%
SGC SGC 2,880 · 0.0%
Beckett Beckett 865 · 0.0%
CGC CGC 112 · 0.0%
Total 11,128 · 0.0%
Full grade table
Grade PSAPSA SGCSGC BeckettBeckett CGCCGC
10 1 – – –
9 15 5 – –
8.5 10 9 2 –
8 195 21 12 –
7.5 20 18 17 –
7 490 71 35 –
6.5 35 20 32 4
6 940 152 64 4
5.5 64 93 75 11
5 1,099 346 107 12
4.5 85 170 78 3
4 1,424 441 106 6
Total 7,271 2,880 865 112
Pop data powered by GemRate, updated Oct 19, 2026. Counts change as new cards are graded.
Card details

1957 Topps Ted Williams #1 baseball card, graded PSA 5 by Professional Sports Authenticator. This card comes from the 1957 Topps set and features Ted Williams, one of the key names in the Topps baseball issue from that year. The card is listed with a PSA population of 1 and a higher population of 1, making it a documented example from the set for collectors focused on vintage baseball and Hall of Fame subjects.

Listed1 day ago
Card TypeGraded
GraderPSA
Grade5
CategoryBaseball
More from Mascot